| Name | Year |
| George D. Stahley '71 * | 1935 |
| Charles Baum '74 * | 1936 |
| Jeremiah Zimmerman '73 * | 1936 |
| John B. McAlister '84 * | 1937 |
| Milton H. Valentine '82 * | 1937 |
| William J. Gies '93 * | 1938 |
| Percy D. Hoover '89 * | 1938 |
| George H. Hummel '13 * | 1939 |
| Paul R. Sieber '07 * | 1939 |
| Charles T. Lark, Jr. '43 * | 1940 |
| William B. Keefer '95 * | 1940 |
| Samuel G. Hefelbower '91 * | 1940 |
| Charles M. A. Stine '01 * | 1941 |
| Edward Ehlers '98 * | 1942 |
| Hiram H. Keller '01 * | 1943 |
| Frederick H. Knubel '93 * | 1943 |
| Henry W.A. Hanson, III '54 * | 1944 |
| C. Paul Cessna '15 * | 1944 |
| Joseph B. Baker, Sr. '01 * | 1945 |
| Clarence L. S. Raby '09 * | 1945 |
| Clyde E. Gerberich '13 * | 1947 |
| Stewart W. Herman '99 * | 1947 |
| Lewis C. Manges, Sr. '97 * | 1948 |
| Raymond M. Miller '35 * | 1948 |
| Horace G. Ports, Sr. '25 * | 1948 |
| Chester G. Crist '08 * | 1949 |
| Paul Froehlich '04 * | 1949 |
| C. William Duncan '17 * | 1950 |
| William H. Patrick, Jr. '16 * | 1950 |
| Mildred Dimmerling Johnson '33 | 1951 |
| George B. Baker '20 * | 1952 |
| James S. Glaes '16 * | 1952 |
| Frank A. Kister '13 * | 1953 |
| Nelson F. Fisher '18 * | 1954 |
| Frederick R. Seibel, Jr. '26 * | 1954 |
| John A. Apple '19 * | 1955 |
| Charles B. McCollough, Sr. '16 * | 1955 |
| E. Lloyd Rothfuss '16 * | 1956 |
| John Aberly '88 * | 1956 |
| Frank H. Kramer '14 * | 1957 |
| J. Walter Singmaster '04 * | 1957 |
| Henry T. Bream '24 * | 1958 |
| Ralph W. Hoch '16 * | 1958 |
| Lester E. Gingerich '22 * | 1959 |
| Charles R. Wolfe '23 * | 1959 |
| Millard E. Gladfelter '25 * | 1960 |
| William H. B. Stevens '26 * | 1960 |
| John S. Rice '21 * | 1961 |
| Bruce U. P. Cobaugh '05 * | 1962 |
| N. Jay Gould Wickey '12 * | 1962 |
| Paul B. Dunbar '04 * | 1963 |
| John B. Zinn '09 * | 1963 |
| Lavern H. Brenneman '36 | 1964 |
| Carl W. Munshower '24 * | 1964 |
| William C. Waltemyer '08 * | 1965 |
| Donald K. Weiser '24 * | 1965 |
| Harry F. Baughman '10 * | 1966 |
| Ralph W. McCreary '18 * | 1966 |
| Charles W. Diehl, Jr. '29 * | 1967 |
| Luella Musselman Paul '31 * | 1967 |
| J. Donald Glenn '23 * | 1968 |
| Henry M. Scharf '25 * | 1968 |
| Robert B. Mathias '22 * | 1969 |
| Paul H. Rhoads '28 * | 1969 |
| John M. Musselman '39 * | 1970 |
| Earl E. Ziegler '21 * | 1970 |
| Dwight F. Putman '20 * | 1971 |
| Arthur S. Sipe '26 * | 1971 |
| Jack E. Nightingale, Sr. '53 * | 1972 |
| Hugh E. Yost '24 * | 1972 |
| Ray A. Barnard '15 * | 1973 |
| John W. Doub, Sr. '22 * | 1973 |
| Edward H. Buck '18 * | 1974 |
| Levi D. Mumper '29 * | 1974 |
| Alfred L. Mathias '26 * | 1975 |
| Raymond M. Miller '35 * | 1975 |
| Robert D. Hanson '39 * | 1976 |
| Frederick P. Weidner '25 * | 1976 |
| Rosea A. Armor* | 1977 |
| Norman G. Asbury '26 * | 1977 |
| Ralph W. Cox '42 * | 1978 |
| Henry W. Graybill, Jr. '49 | 1978 |
| Paul E. Stein '30 * | 1979 |
| F. William Sunderman '19 * | 1979 |
| James H. Hartzell '24 * | 1980 |
| Earl K. Stock '19 * | 1980 |
| G. Joseph Kurtz '54 * |
1981 |
| Richard E. Walker, Sr. '37 * | 1981 |
| Harry L. Graybill '24 * | 1982 |
| Roscoe L. Strawn '59 * | 1982 |
| G. Bowers Mansdorfer '26 * | 1983 |
| Harold R. Schriver '28 * | 1983 |
| Martin F. Peters '37 * | 1984 |
| John B. Zinn, Jr. '41 | 1984 |
| Louise Dougherty Bream '25 * | 1985 |
| George W. Dress, Jr. '31 * | 1985 |
| Milton V. Burgess '22 * | 1986 |
| William R. McElhiney '36 * | 1986 |
| Ellis R. McCracken '37 * | 1987 |
| Jack E. Rice '47 * | 1987 |
| Robert H. Janke '48 * | 1988 |
| C. Allen Sloat '23 * | 1988 |
| Jack D. Bream '57 | 1989 |
| Henry M. Koch, Sr. '29 * | 1989 |
| Samuel A. Schreckengaust, Jr. '35* | 1990 |
| Irvin G. Zimmerman '40 * | 1990 |
| Harold A. Dunkelberger '36 | 1991 |
| Vivian Wickey Otto '46 | 1991 |
| Ralph Mahaffie '22 * | 1992 |
| John C. Stahle '40 * | 1992 |
| H. Bruce Riefe '43 * | 1993 |
| Raymond F. Sheely '33 * | 1993 |
| Carolyn Kuhn Byron '62 | 1994 |
| Arthur D. Hunger, Jr. '39 | 1994 |
| Thomas C. Norris '60 | 1995 |
| Luther W. Ritter '33 * | 1995 |
| Robert E. O'Brien '51 | 1996 |
| Ralph E. Sentz '49 * | 1996 |
| Margaret Blanchard Curtis '52 | 1997 |
| Ernest J. Kruse '52 | 1997 |
| Robert H. Fryling '43 * | 1998 |
| Susan White Keers '53 * | 1998 |
| William H. Keers, Jr. '53 | 1998 |
| Elmer S. McKee '44 | 1999 |
| Glenn S. Pannell, Sr. '54 | 1999 |
| Mary Jane Callis Brenneman '60 | 2000 |
| Ruthe Fortenbaugh Craley '50 | 2000 |
| William Harral, III '61 | 2001 |
| Bruce R. Stefany '71 | 2001 |
| Al Reese '50 * | 2002 |
| Virginia Saul Reese '51 | 2002 |
| Thomas P. Gearey '52 * | 2003 |
| Kristine F. Hughey '68 | 2003 |
| James G. Apple '58 | 2004 |
| William T. Kirchhoff '63 | 2004 |
| William C. Heyman '74 | 2005 |
| Gregory Islan '70 | 2005 |
| Kenneth C. Lundeen '66 | 2006 |
| David A. Radin '65 | 2006 |
| Paul R. Haldeman '67 | 2007 |
| Susan Gibble Wolf '57 | 2007 |
| Christopher M. Re '78 | 2008 |
| Maria Caracciolo Weisensee '83 | 2008 |
| Robert A. MacFarland '67 | 2009 |
| Barbara Turner White '74 | 2009 |
| Bruce & Sherrin Hilburt Baky '65 | 2010 |
| Cheryl Walker Davis '75 | 2010 |
| William M. Matz, Jr. '61 | 2011 |
| Lorna Rice '81 | 2011 |
| I. Charles Widger | 2012 |
| Suzanne Hermann Williams | 2012 |
*deceased
